If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
How can Carnival do this - Holiday Ship - What happened to the ship?
Holiday Cruise Ship leaving 12-30-2004
I just got a call from an very upset friend waiting to board the Holiday at the Mobile, Alabama port. All they know is something with the ship is broken. They said they each were issued $100 onboard credit, and the Holiday New Year Cruise the Western Carribean has had the itinerary changed to a cruise to NOWHERE. No other explanation. As everyone knows - the prices are much higher at this time of year and $200 per cabin is not much compensation. Seems like they could at least go to Key West, FL. Does anyone know what happened to the ship? What options do passengers have? |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
http://www.al.com/news/mobileregiste...8826574620.xml
It looks like they did offer to let the people get a refund if they didn't want to cruise. Bobbye wrote in message oups.com... I call this being . They have been having engine trouble for the last 2 weeks. Carnival never attempted to call any passengers at home to notify them of the changes. Christmas and New Years Cruises are the most expensive prices and Carnival makes their best profits from these cruises, no matter how deceitful they have to be to get a passenger's money. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Thanks. Happy New Year to you and everyone else.
--Tom "Dick Goldhaber" wrote in message ... Hey, Tom and Linda, I haven't seen the ball drop in Times Square for at least a decade, but I absolutely will this evening. A Happy New Year to the two of you from the three of us. -- DG in Cherry Hill, NJ "Tom & Linda" wrote in message ... Just Fake It. Then read it. "David Gee" wrote in message news:yJnBd.38454$dv1.11489@edtnps89... They want me to register to look at a news clipping? Not bloody likely! Slimy list spammers .... "Bobbye" wrote in message ... http://www.al.com/news/mobileregiste...448826574620.x ml It looks like they did offer to let the people get a refund if they didn't want to cruise. Bobbye wrote in message oups.com... I call this being . They have been having engine trouble for the last 2 weeks. Carnival never attempted to call any passengers at home to notify them of the changes. Christmas and New Years Cruises are the most expensive prices and Carnival makes their best profits from these cruises, no matter how deceitful they have to be to get a passenger's money. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
"David Gee" wrote in message news:yJnBd.38454$dv1.11489@edtnps89... They want me to register to look at a news clipping? Not bloody likely! Slimy list spammers ... Here is the article, from Friday's Mobile Register: David Jacobson Baton Rouge Ship problems mar New Year's cruise on Carnival's Holiday Friday, December 31, 2004 By EDDIE CURRAN Staff Reporter Barry Jones and his wife, Elizabeth, drove seven hours from Athens, Ga., to Mobile's cruise-ship terminal. He was anticipating a walk among the Mayan ruins near Cozumel, and she was looking forward to basking in the warm Caribbean rays aboard Carnival's cruise ship Holiday. But Thursday afternoon, cruise-line officials told the Joneses and some 1,700 others that the Holiday, slowed by mechanical problems, couldn't reach Cozumel and instead would simply motor around in the Gulf of Mexico until Monday. In an effort to put a good face on the situation, Carnival officials dubbed the four-day voyage the "Cruise-To-Nowhere." "They told us it might only go 30 or 40 miles south of here," said Jones, in explaining why he and his wife chose to get their money back rather than stay aboard. "We're just going to float about in the water?" said another man, upon arriving at the terminal gate and hearing the news. Those who proceeded with the voyage are receiving a $100-per-passenger credit on their Sail & Sign shipboard account, which can be used for drinks, spa treatments, gift shop items and virtually anything for sale on the ship, said Carnival public relations manager Vance Gullikson. "Believe me, we apologize for this," Gullikson said. "This is not something we plan on. We feel terrible about disrupting people's plans, especially on New Year's when it's a very popular time for vacation." About 5 percent of the passengers canceled after learning the news, Gullikson said. "Obviously, the vast majority opted to go on this cruise," he said. Because of security, it was not possible for reporters to board the ship to interview passengers. As a result, most of those who could be reached for comment were departing, including Jim Thornton of Nashville. "I'll tell you, to drive all the way down here, it puts a very sour taste in your mouth," Thornton said. "They're just going to go out in the Gulf and circle around. I don't need to spend $1,500 cruising around in the Gulf of Mexico." Thornton and his wife, Margaret, arrived in the morning and spent most of the day on the Holiday, first preparing to enjoy their trip and the last two hours waiting for staff to locate their luggage. "There were an awful lot of sour people onboard," Jim Thornton said. "We saw children crying. There were people who'd come down from places like Ohio and Wisconsin." A couple with two children had no time to talk about their decision to cancel because -- as the man hurriedly said from the back seat of a taxi -- they had to be in Pensacola in an hour for a flight back to Massachusetts. Originally, passengers were to spend Thursday night and today at sea and arrive at Cozumel, the Mexican island resort, at 8 a.m. Saturday. They were to spend nine hours in port and cruise back to Mobile, arriving at 8 a.m. Monday. The Holiday's condition not only puts a damper on this weekend's trip but also raises concerns about the ship's next venture, a five-day cruise scheduled to depart late Monday afternoon. As soon as the Holiday concludes the Cruise-To-Nowhere, company technicians will board the ship in an effort to fix the problem in time for that afternoon's departure. "The only thing we can tell them (passengers on Monday's trip) is that we're still assessing this and will have more information as we get closer to the departure date," Gullikson said. The Holiday, the only cruise ship that operates out of Mobile, is the smallest and oldest vessel in Carnival's fleet. The company's inaugural voyage from Mobile left for Mexico on Oct. 16 from Mobile Landing, site of the $20 million cruise terminal built for Carnival's use. On Thursday afternoon, incoming passengers arriving at the terminal parking garage were handed written notices of the ship's problems. The flier explained why the Holiday wouldn't be going to Cozumel and informed passengers that they could get a refund or, if they chose to sail, receive the $100 spending credit. One couple, Elwood Hogan and Elizabeth Hogan of Gulf Shores, said they were disappointed with the news but chose to go anyway. Their main purpose was to be aboard at midnight to celebrate New Year's, and that's where they'd be regardless of the change in plans. Unlike Jim Thornton, Elwood Hogan -- who left the ship and was returning to board -- said he hadn't heard many complaints, and "I'm a little surprised," he said. Thornton and his wife also criticized Carnival for not providing something in addition to a straight refund, as airlines often do when they bump passengers from a flight. "There were no decent apologies, and the ones who were most helpful finding our luggage were the dock workers," Jim Thornton said. As of late Thursday, Gullikson was unable to say how far south the boat would sail. He said he believed the ship would "take a slow sail around the ocean, just a nice relaxing sail and then come back into port" on Monday. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Thus spake "Tom & Linda" :
Just Fake It. Then read it. www.bugmenot.com "David Gee" wrote in message news:yJnBd.38454$dv1.11489@edtnps89... They want me to register to look at a news clipping? Not bloody likely! Slimy list spammers .... "Bobbye" wrote in message ... http://www.al.com/news/mobileregiste...8826574620.xml It looks like they did offer to let the people get a refund if they didn't want to cruise. Bobbye wrote in message oups.com... I call this being . They have been having engine trouble for the last 2 weeks. Carnival never attempted to call any passengers at home to notify them of the changes. Christmas and New Years Cruises are the most expensive prices and Carnival makes their best profits from these cruises, no matter how deceitful they have to be to get a passenger's money. -- dillon "When the French are against it, you know we can't be far wrong." - Adm. Bobbie Ray Inman |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
I'm not someone who takes every opportunity to accuse corporations of being greedy at the expense of passengers. But, if they can't provide a satisfactory level of service to passengers on the Holiday, why do they risk their reputation by keeping the ship running in this condition? Carnival is the #1 cruise company for one reason (they even bought out Princess with the money they brought in). People want to cheap out and they are the ones to give it to them. There is no shortage of people who want "hit and run" 3-5 day cruising experiences for cheap. Cruises are not something that should be scrimped on. People want or expect the best but want only want to pay Asian sweat shop prices. If you want good, you will have to pay for it but if you want cheap-O, you get cheap-O. Next Christmas, go to the dollar store and buy all of the children in your life $1 toys. See how long they last and how happy they are with them. You get what you pay for. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
I think you misunderstood my point. I'm not justifying their lack of
quality....I'm questioning why they'd continue to do something that's not top-notch. The last cruise I went on was a Empress deck room on the Conquest to Western Caribbean. I agree -- you get what you pay for. Tony On Sun, 02 Jan 2005 13:06:40 -0600, Eden wrote: I'm not someone who takes every opportunity to accuse corporations of being greedy at the expense of passengers. But, if they can't provide a satisfactory level of service to passengers on the Holiday, why do they risk their reputation by keeping the ship running in this condition? Carnival is the #1 cruise company for one reason (they even bought out Princess with the money they brought in). People want to cheap out and they are the ones to give it to them. There is no shortage of people who want "hit and run" 3-5 day cruising experiences for cheap. Cruises are not something that should be scrimped on. People want or expect the best but want only want to pay Asian sweat shop prices. If you want good, you will have to pay for it but if you want cheap-O, you get cheap-O. Next Christmas, go to the dollar store and buy all of the children in your life $1 toys. See how long they last and how happy they are with them. You get what you pay for. Tony Rush |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Thus spake Charles :
In article , Tony Rush wrote: This s slightly offtopic but my father-in-law and his wife just returned from their first cruise ever. They'd chosen a 5-day out of Mobile on the Holiday and came back not very excited. They said the food wasn't good at all and other passengers were also complaining. Was this one of the cruises affected by the Holiday engine problems? That might have put people in a sour mood. Also I think someone posted that the Holiday is the oldest ship in the fleet. From what I have read the food isn't as good on the older Carnival ships as the newer builds. I have been on one Carnival ship, one of the newest, Miracle and the food was very good. I would not cruise Carnival again except under exceptional circumstances, because they are a poor fit for me, not my general style, but it is a good fit for many who feel comfortable onboard Carnival. We were on the Celebration last year. Pretty happy with the food and service. Talked to some people from the Holiday, they weren't too happy. Maybe it's a ship problem. -- dillon "When the French are against it, you know we can't be far wrong." - Adm. Bobbie Ray Inman |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Can you imagine the furor if CCL had canceled the cruise? All those people,
with air and hotel rooms paid for and then with nothing to do once they got to Mobile? Not even a room to stay in because it might well have been booked? Over NEW YEAR'S EVE? Just what else do you think they should have done? These people were given a choice, they may have missed going to Cozumel, but at least they didn't lose out on their party venue and they were give $100 credit per cabin. wrote in message ups.com... Holiday Cruise Ship leaving 12-30-2004 I just got a call from an very upset friend waiting to board the Holiday at the Mobile, Alabama port. All they know is something with the ship is broken. They said they each were issued $100 onboard credit, and the Holiday New Year Cruise the Western Carribean has had the itinerary changed to a cruise to NOWHERE. No other explanation. As everyone knows - the prices are much higher at this time of year and $200 per cabin is not much compensation. Seems like they could at least go to Key West, FL. Does anyone know what happened to the ship? What options do passengers have? |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Take the cruise line to small claims court. You may be lucky enough to have
a sympathetic judge. In fact we all should start using this tactic as a weapon against these arrogant travel conglomerates. Sooner or later they MAY get the message. wrote in message ups.com... Holiday Cruise Ship leaving 12-30-2004 I just got a call from an very upset friend waiting to board the Holiday at the Mobile, Alabama port. All they know is something with the ship is broken. They said they each were issued $100 onboard credit, and the Holiday New Year Cruise the Western Carribean has had the itinerary changed to a cruise to NOWHERE. No other explanation. As everyone knows - the prices are much higher at this time of year and $200 per cabin is not much compensation. Seems like they could at least go to Key West, FL. Does anyone know what happened to the ship? What options do passengers have? |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Carnival Quarter & Full Year Earnings! | Ray Goldenberg | Cruises | 0 | December 16th, 2004 03:29 PM |
Carnival Earnings Rise Sharply! | Ray Goldenberg | Cruises | 2 | March 23rd, 2004 04:56 AM |
Carnival Corp Orders Ship for Costa! | Ray Goldenberg | Cruises | 0 | January 19th, 2004 02:55 PM |
Delayed cruise review - Carnival Triumph (VERY LONG) | Thomas Smith | Cruises | 11 | December 31st, 2003 07:23 AM |
Top 25 Rated Five-Star Cruise Ships! | Ray Goldenberg | Cruises | 10 | December 26th, 2003 07:43 PM |