If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
is this true about US forking habits?
BBC London (a local station staffed mainly by idiot presenters
interested only in celebrity trivia and themselves, not to be confused with things like Radio 4 or BB1 and 2) just said that the (alleged*) US habit of cutting up food first with the knife then eating with a fork only originated in the poverty of western settlers who only had one knife in the family, sounds as likely as William Tell to me, what do those of you in a position to know think? * i dont recollect seeing any americans doing it and some deny it exists -- Mike Remove clothing to email |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
is this true about US forking habits?
"Mike.." wrote in message ... BBC London (a local station staffed mainly by idiot presenters interested only in celebrity trivia and themselves, not to be confused with things like Radio 4 or BB1 and 2) just said that the (alleged*) US habit of cutting up food first with the knife then eating with a fork only originated in the poverty of western settlers who only had one knife in the family, sounds as likely as William Tell to me, what do those of you in a position to know think? * i dont recollect seeing any americans doing it and some deny it exists I've heard the same story from Americans. I've also noticed the practice is common in the USA. Some years back (in the 1980s when I travelled to the USA a lot), someone at the next table said "Excuse me, are you English?". When I answered and asked what had given me away, it was the fact that I was eating with a knife and fork. -- 73 Brian, G8OSN www.g8osn.org.uk |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
is this true about US forking habits?
"Mike.." ha scritto nel messaggio
... BBC London (a local station staffed mainly by idiot presenters interested only in celebrity trivia and themselves, not to be confused with things like Radio 4 or BB1 and 2) just said that the (alleged*) US habit of cutting up food first with the knife then eating with a fork only originated in the poverty of western settlers who only had one knife in the family, sounds as likely as William Tell to me, what do those of you in a position to know think? * i dont recollect seeing any americans doing it and some deny it exists -- Mike No, everybody eats that way from the always rich to the still poor. Except those who eat with their fingers. The process is described in every etiquette book. Yanno, there are any number of US familes who were never poor at all. Until now, if you have to buy sterling or euro. OTH, things do alter a bit when forking around, forking up etc. -- http://www.judithgreenwood.com |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
is this true about US forking habits?
Oh pshaw, on Sun 18 Nov 2007 05:00:17a, Mike.. meant to say...
BBC London (a local station staffed mainly by idiot presenters interested only in celebrity trivia and themselves, not to be confused with things like Radio 4 or BB1 and 2) just said that the (alleged*) US habit of cutting up food first with the knife then eating with a fork only originated in the poverty of western settlers who only had one knife in the family, sounds as likely as William Tell to me, what do those of you in a position to know think? * i dont recollect seeing any americans doing it and some deny it exists I was taught to cut one bite of food (fork in left hand, knife in right hand), place the knife on the edge of the plate, switch the fork to the right hand and eat the food. This was to be done in repetition for each bite one must cut. Everyone in my family eats this way, as do most of the people I know. This I know as "American Style". I have also seen people hold the fork in the left hand and the knife in the right hand thoroughout the meal, cutting pieces as they eat and not switching the fork from hand to hand. This I know as "European Style". Either American or European style are considered correct. Having said that, I have seen some people in restaurants cut up every bite of food all at once, put the knife down and the proceed to eat. Occasionally they will use the knife to help "scoop" something onto their fork. I was taught that this was bad manners. Another strange variation I have seen on occasion is holding both the knife and fork almost straight up in a fist like grasp. There are some appalling eaters here. :-) I have lived my entire life in the USS and have never heard this "theory" about the reason for cutting up all of one's food at once. I was only taught that it was improper. You might find this interesting... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fork_etiquette -- ¦ A mind is a terrible thing to lose... ¦ |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
is this true about US forking habits?
Mike.. surprised us with
originated in the poverty of western settlers who only had one knife in the family Imagine an utterly poor family of twelve: with twelve forks and 1 (one) knife. Completely ridiculous. If poverty would be a consideration, wouldn't logic dictate that every family member had a multipurpose knife, and possibly the family as a whole might own a single fork, for forking purposes? -- *** Waldo *** Despite the high cost of living, it remains a popular item. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
is this true about US forking habits?
Wayne Boatwright wrote:
Oh pshaw, on Sun 18 Nov 2007 05:00:17a, Mike.. meant to say... BBC London (a local station staffed mainly by idiot presenters interested only in celebrity trivia and themselves, not to be confused with things like Radio 4 or BB1 and 2) just said that the (alleged*) US habit of cutting up food first with the knife then eating with a fork only originated in the poverty of western settlers who only had one knife in the family, sounds as likely as William Tell to me, what do those of you in a position to know think? * i dont recollect seeing any americans doing it and some deny it exists I was taught to cut one bite of food (fork in left hand, knife in right hand), place the knife on the edge of the plate, switch the fork to the right hand and eat the food. This was to be done in repetition for each bite one must cut. Everyone in my family eats this way, as do most of the people I know. This I know as "American Style". Didn't anyone in your family realise that it's absurd to switch the fork to the rght hand when it's already in your left hand, and likely to have the next mouthful already impaled on it? What's the point? It's about as absurd as eating with two thin sticks of wood, but I'd better not go down that path ... :-) -- Richard J. (to e-mail me, change 'ten' to 'net' in address) www.stayparis.net |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
is this true about US forking habits?
|
#8
|
|||
|
|||
is this true about US forking habits?
Sacha wrote on Sun, 18 Nov 2007 13:09:24 +0000:
?? BBC London (a local station staffed mainly by idiot ?? presenters interested only in celebrity trivia and ?? themselves, not to be confused with things like Radio 4 or ?? BB1 and 2) just said that the (alleged*) US habit of ?? cutting up food first with the knife then eating with ?? a fork only originated in the poverty of western settlers ?? who only had one knife in the family, sounds as likely as ?? William Tell to me, what do those of you in a position to ?? know think? ?? ?? * i dont recollect seeing any americans doing it and some ?? deny it exists S Don't know about the origins but I've seen many Americans do S it. In fact, I thought it originated here when people used S their dagger to cut meat and then spear it, then cleaned it, S so that it could be used for its intended purpose, if need S be! Isn't the fork a comparatively recent invention? Dickens, I forget where, called the American way of eating a "horrible German custom". I always understood that, despite the fact that hand switching is inefficient, it was ill-mannered to cut up more than a bight or two at a time.It is not hard to learn either "European" or "American" style; my kids did it for their first trip abroad (ages 7 and 9) and used to enjoy using the European method tho' they switched back on returning home. Apropos oriental "sticks" as was mentioned, their use is not difficult to learn once you realize that the motion of the upper chop stick is similar to using a pencil. Again, my kids learned to use chopsticks at about the same age as they learned "European eating. After we asked for four sets of chopsticks, the kitchen staff sneaked out to watch them in a Chinese restaurant in Gallup, New Mexico :-) I have found that once I told European visitors about the pencil motion, they learned very quickly and, as the Thais who use a spoon and fork for most else demonstrate, chopsticks are possibly the best implements for noodles. James Silverton Potomac, Maryland E-mail, with obvious alterations: not.jim.silverton.at.verizon.not |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
is this true about US forking habits?
"Wayne Boatwright" wrote in message 6.120... Oh pshaw, on Sun 18 Nov 2007 05:00:17a, Mike.. meant to say... Another strange variation I have seen on occasion is holding both the knife and fork almost straight up in a fist like grasp. There are some appalling eaters here. :-) I've seen that all too often in Canadian restos too, especially when they are eating steak! In fact, at the annual cycle club club dinner last night, a young uni post grad was cutting up some prime Alberta beef that way. At least he was chewing with his mouth closed! Graham |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
is this true about US forking habits?
Waldo Centini wrote:
Mike.. surprised us with originated in the poverty of western settlers who only had one knife in the family Imagine an utterly poor family of twelve: with twelve forks and 1 (one) knife. Completely ridiculous. If poverty would be a consideration, wouldn't logic dictate that every family member had a multipurpose knife, and possibly the family as a whole might own a single fork, for forking purposes? G |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
driving habits in Europe | [email protected] | Europe | 282 | October 12th, 2006 09:40 AM |
Healthy habits | G Strategic | Europe | 0 | March 1st, 2006 11:09 AM |
Habits in Australia | Chris2900 | Cruises | 9 | March 7th, 2004 01:19 AM |
Spending Habits of Cruisers! | Ray Goldenberg | Cruises | 11 | November 12th, 2003 08:43 PM |