If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Buy backpack with frame or not?
I need a backpack to go traveling with. I need to put my laptop
computer in it (to help disguise it and hence prevent theft), but don't want the kind of backpack thats designed to carry a laptop. I will put the laptop in its padded case and put the case inside the backpack. I also want the backpack to hold lots of other stuff too, so it has to be fairly big. I don't know anything about backpacks, unfortunately. I've always used cheap ones and I have one problem with them--my back sweats heavily and this gets the pack dirty after a while. I have started shopping and I see that there are packs with two long aluminum things attached beneath the shoulder straps. I assume this is what is called an "external frame" backpack. Can anyone tell me what the advantage is of a backpack with a frame over one that doesnt have a frame? In my case, putting a heavy (12 pound) laptop in the case, along with a lot of other stuff, is an external frame going to help this be easier to carry? But what do I do when I want to give the backpack a bath? How can you water-clean it with those aluminum things stuck in there? The ones I saw in the (cheap) store did not seem to be removable, but I could be wrong. I think I read somewhere that the external frame prevents the back sweating problem. Is this true? Thanks for your assistance. |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Buy backpack with frame or not?
There a lots of pros and cons on the two designs and I'm sure you'll get a lot
more detailed comparisons from others. You need to consider how you'll use the pack, when (2 or 4 season), your build, and load. To get you started, you might take a look at: http://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backpack. It is a start at some of your selection criteria. Jay On 10/10/2003 10:46 AM, Lehar V. Osvald wrote: Can anyone tell me what the advantage is of a backpack with a frame over one that doesnt have a frame? I think I read somewhere that the external frame prevents the back sweating problem. Is this true? |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Buy backpack with frame or not?
"Lehar V. Osvald" schrieb im Newsbeitrag om... I don't know anything about backpacks, unfortunately. I've always used cheap ones and I have one problem with them--my back sweats heavily and this gets the pack dirty after a while. I have started shopping and I see that there are packs with two long aluminum things attached beneath the shoulder straps. I assume this is what is called an "external frame" backpack. How many litres you want the pack to have space for? If you want less than around 45 you might want to consider the deuter series. Their air comfort system has a mesh suspended by two slim spring steel blades that tighten the mesh even more once the pack is loaded. It has a real airspace between the mesh and the pack. http://www.deuter.com/cms/front_content.php?idcat=70 If you want more than 50L you probably want a pack with a REAL good hip belt so that the pack sits on top of your hip and the shoulder straps only prevent the pack from falling off. Then you can loosen the straps to such a degree that the pack dangles around your back as much as you are willing to tolerate. Lots of Greetings! Volker |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Buy backpack with frame or not?
"Lehar V. Osvald" wrote in message om... I don't know anything about backpacks, unfortunately. I've always used cheap ones and I have one problem with them--my back sweats heavily and this gets the pack dirty after a while. I have started shopping and I see that there are packs with two long aluminum things attached beneath the shoulder straps. I assume this is what is called an "external frame" backpack. The long aluminum things you describe are called 'stays'. The are used in larger internal packs to provide support and enhance the suspension of the pack. An external frame pack has a tubular rack on the outside of the pack. .. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Buy backpack with frame or not?
Hello Lehar:
The best pack for you is found by trying them on for fit. I have two packs one external for long hauls, one internal for mountianeering. Don't be shy once you're in the store, put some weight in the pack have the retailer show you the adjustment features, and walk around for a while. Chris "Lehar V. Osvald" wrote in message om... I need a backpack to go traveling with. I need to put my laptop computer in it (to help disguise it and hence prevent theft), but don't want the kind of backpack thats designed to carry a laptop. I will put the laptop in its padded case and put the case inside the backpack. I also want the backpack to hold lots of other stuff too, so it has to be fairly big. I don't know anything about backpacks, unfortunately. I've always used cheap ones and I have one problem with them--my back sweats heavily and this gets the pack dirty after a while. I have started shopping and I see that there are packs with two long aluminum things attached beneath the shoulder straps. I assume this is what is called an "external frame" backpack. Can anyone tell me what the advantage is of a backpack with a frame over one that doesnt have a frame? In my case, putting a heavy (12 pound) laptop in the case, along with a lot of other stuff, is an external frame going to help this be easier to carry? But what do I do when I want to give the backpack a bath? How can you water-clean it with those aluminum things stuck in there? The ones I saw in the (cheap) store did not seem to be removable, but I could be wrong. I think I read somewhere that the external frame prevents the back sweating problem. Is this true? Thanks for your assistance. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Buy backpack with frame or not?
"Lehar V. Osvald" wrote:
I need a backpack to go traveling with. I need to put my laptop computer in it (to help disguise it and hence prevent theft), but don't want the kind of backpack thats designed to carry a laptop. I will put the laptop in its padded case and put the case inside the backpack. I also want the backpack to hold lots of other stuff too, so it has to be fairly big. I don't know anything about backpacks, unfortunately. I've always used cheap ones and I have one problem with them--my back sweats heavily and this gets the pack dirty after a while. I have started shopping and I see that there are packs with two long aluminum things attached beneath the shoulder straps. I assume this is what is called an "external frame" backpack. Can anyone tell me what the advantage is of a backpack with a frame over one that doesnt have a frame? In my case, putting a heavy (12 pound) laptop in the case, along with a lot of other stuff, is an external frame going to help this be easier to carry? But what do I do when I want to give the backpack a bath? How can you water-clean it with those aluminum things stuck in there? The ones I saw in the (cheap) store did not seem to be removable, but I could be wrong. I think I read somewhere that the external frame prevents the back sweating problem. Is this true? Thanks for your assistance. ================================================== =========== If your pack will involve airline travel I'd get an internal frame. Backpacks don't take baths. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Buy backpack with frame or not?
Thanks for the advice. I see now that the backpacks I'm looking at are
not external frame, they are just cheap backpacks with those aluminum stays (which I found out today can be removed.) I'm not looking at $300 backpacks, I'm looking in discount stores at $12 to $20 backpacks (of course, I'm living in a third world country, so these packs are probably the same as $50 backpacks you might find in Wal-Mart or wherever) I'm not sure how many liters I'm looking for, I just kind of look at the backpack and ask myself if it's about the size I need. So what is the advantage of these aluminum stays? I could get a cheap pack with them or without them. Thanks everyone. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Buy backpack with frame or not?
Thanks for the advice. I see now that the backpacks I'm looking at are
not external frame, they are just cheap backpacks with those aluminum stays (which I found out today can be removed.) I'm not looking at $300 backpacks, I'm looking in discount stores at $12 to $20 backpacks (of course, I'm living in a third world country, so these packs are probably the same as $50 backpacks you might find in Wal-Mart or wherever) I'm not sure how many liters I'm looking for, I just kind of look at the backpack and ask myself if it's about the size I need. So what is the advantage of these aluminum stays? I could get a cheap pack with them or without them. The stays give the pack support, so it doesn't hug your back like a limp noodle. The stays also help transfer the load off of your shoulders and onto your hip (via the hip belt), which gives the shoulders some relief. You should give the most consideration to the shoulder straps and hipbelt, as these components will dictate whether the pack will be comfortable or not. If you are looking for a pack that will allow your back to breathe more, you might want to consider an external frame pack (one with external stays). You see, the aluminum stays and mesh backing create a void between your back and the pack itself, thus allowing air to circulate, and thus keeping your back cool. Internal frame packs, on the other hand, rest right up against your back, which prevents air from circulating between your back and the pack, and which results in a sweaty back. Some newer, more expensive I-frame (internal stays) packs have designs that allow your back to breathe, but it sounds like these are beyond your budget. My $.02, RD |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Buy backpack with frame or not?
"Lehar V. Osvald" wrote:
Thanks for the advice. I see now that the backpacks I'm looking at are not external frame, they are just cheap backpacks with those aluminum stays (which I found out today can be removed.) I'm not looking at $300 backpacks, I'm looking in discount stores at $12 to $20 backpacks (of course, I'm living in a third world country, so these packs are probably the same as $50 backpacks you might find in Wal-Mart or wherever) I'm not sure how many liters I'm looking for, I just kind of look at the backpack and ask myself if it's about the size I need. So what is the advantage of these aluminum stays? I could get a cheap pack with them or without them. Thanks everyone. ================================================== === The internal stays are a very good thing. Without them it's just a rucksack. For comfort, the more frame the better. I could get in to higher ultralight philosophies like the contents of the pack are the frame. i.e. if you jam-pack everything into a bag it becomes stiff. But that's beyond your needs or understanding. Just get a pack with internal aluminum or titanium stays and you're done. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Buy backpack with frame or not?
Since travel is your primary use, I'd go with an internal frame travel
type pack. The frame packs will be too bulky for travel. Many manufacturers make packs that have handles on the side and zip away straps, to convert your pack to a suitcase. LL Bean sells a nice one and most major pack manufacturers have at least one in their line. Lehar V. Osvald wrote: I need a backpack to go traveling with. I need to put my laptop computer in it (to help disguise it and hence prevent theft), but don't want the kind of backpack thats designed to carry a laptop. I will put the laptop in its padded case and put the case inside the backpack. I also want the backpack to hold lots of other stuff too, so it has to be fairly big. I don't know anything about backpacks, unfortunately. I've always used cheap ones and I have one problem with them--my back sweats heavily and this gets the pack dirty after a while. I have started shopping and I see that there are packs with two long aluminum things attached beneath the shoulder straps. I assume this is what is called an "external frame" backpack. Can anyone tell me what the advantage is of a backpack with a frame over one that doesnt have a frame? In my case, putting a heavy (12 pound) laptop in the case, along with a lot of other stuff, is an external frame going to help this be easier to carry? But what do I do when I want to give the backpack a bath? How can you water-clean it with those aluminum things stuck in there? The ones I saw in the (cheap) store did not seem to be removable, but I could be wrong. I think I read somewhere that the external frame prevents the back sweating problem. Is this true? Thanks for your assistance. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Backpack size and what to take on safari? | Dave B | Africa | 3 | April 26th, 2004 09:38 AM |
Wheeled Backpack? | Javaman | Air travel | 13 | March 19th, 2004 01:01 AM |
Backpack Advice | Cloudsteppa | Asia | 3 | December 1st, 2003 08:11 PM |
Travel pack or backpack? | [email protected] | Backpacking and Budget travel | 35 | September 27th, 2003 12:07 PM |
Will bangkok customs cut the padlocks off my backpack? going tomorrow,need help plz! | DON | Asia | 6 | September 21st, 2003 05:44 PM |