If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Times: Rail travellers' guide to becoming a legal fare dodger
The Times
December 27, 2004 Rail travellers' guide to becoming a legal fare dodger By Ben Webster With price rises ahead, it is important for passengers to be more aware of good-value deals THOUSANDS of rail passengers pay too much for their journeys because train companies do not tell them about the cheapest tickets available. Rail fares have become so complex that only those well-versed in the rules and regulations can be reasonably sure of getting the best deal. Passengers have to know to ask for a specific ticket or combination of tickets because train companies are not obliged to advise them of the cheapest fare. One railway enthusiast runs seminars to teach travellers how to play the system to avoid paying over the odds. The secrets of obtaining a bargain on the railways will become more relevant from January 2, when fares will increase by an average of 4 per cent. Further rises are likely because the Government is considering abolishing the price cap on Saver tickets. One of the simplest tricks, which saves money on many routes, is to ask for two return tickets that combine to form a whole journey. A passenger starting out at Peterborough station and asking for a day return to Birmingham will be sold a Saver return for £32.10. However, if he asked for a cheap day return to Melton Mowbray for £6.20 and another from Melton Mowbray to Birmingham for £9.60, the total would be £15.80, less than half the amount requested by the clerk at Peterborough. Another method is to buy a Network Card for £20, with which a passenger at Weymouth could buy a return to Kingıs Lynn for £50.25 instead of the usual price of £76.10 making a saving of £5.85. The passenger could then use the card for the next year to get one third off all his journeys in the South East. It is also possible to save hundreds of pounds a year by buying a season ticket that is never used for the stations it covers. Alex Nelson, who runs a rail travel agency in Chester-le-Street, Co Durham, has a season ticket that covers the route between Ryde Esplanade and Ryde St Johns on the Isle of Wight. The two stations are at opposite ends of the town, and the season ticket is the cheapest in Britain at £104 a year. Mr Nelson lives more than 300 miles from the Isle of Wight but uses the ticket on his regular trips to London. The ticket, as with all season tickets, entitles him to a one-third discount within the Network South East area, which stretches from Exeter to Kingıs Lynn and from Worcester to Hastings. The season ticket also allows him to upgrade to first class for only £3. He has used his ticket on the Isle of Wight only once in four years but saves £100 a year on other journeys. Mr Nelson has uncovered many other money-saving dodges and holds ticketing masterclasses with voluntary groups, including the Womenıs Institute and rotary clubs. Barry Doe, a public transport consultant, said that most of the anomalies had emerged since the railways were privatised. ³Some train companies have been so greedy in pushing up fares that they can hardly complain if people play the system to get a cheaper ticket,² he said. ³In British Rail days, fare rises were done across the system and everything was dovetailed so that you didnıt get these anomalies. "The system would be much fairer and easier to understand if the Strategic Rail Authority set the fares centrally rather than giving the companies freedom to charge what they like." The Rail Passengers Council plans to issue bulletins to passengers advising them how to avoid paying too much. Anthony Smith, the councilıs director, said: ³The fares system is ridiculously complicated and customers need to be very well- informed to negotiate it. "If you are doing anything more complicated than buying a simple point to point return then the different options and restrictions can be bewildering." The Association of Train Operating Companies said that ticket clerks did not always advise passengers of the cheapest deal because it would take too long. A spokeswoman said: "People are perfectly within their rights to ask for those tickets if they want to. Itıs possible in some circumstances they are going to get a cheaper fare." http://www.timesonline.co.uk/newspap...416530,00.html |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
On Mon, 27 Dec 2004 18:42:48 UTC, Biwah wrote:
: The Rail Passengers Council plans to issue bulletins to passengers advising : them how to avoid paying too much. I wonder if railway companies come under the new Freedom of Information Act? Public bodies and organisations providing services for public bodies (in Scotland, I'm not sure of the situation in England) will have to respond to any request for information within 20 days. Anyone like to try writing to Central Trains with a formal FOIA request for the cheaptest day return fare from Peterborough to Birmingham? Ian -- |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Biwah wrote:
The Times December 27, 2004 Rail travellers' guide to becoming a legal fare dodger By Ben Webster Fascinating stuff. Howver,I am reminded that Margaret Thatcher is alleged to have said "a man who finds himself on public transport after the age of 30 can count himself a failure in life. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
"Biwah" wrote in message ... The Times December 27, 2004 Big snip The Association of Train Operating Companies said that ticket clerks did not always advise passengers of the cheapest deal because it would take too long. A spokeswoman said: "People are perfectly within their rights to ask for those tickets if they want to. Itıs possible in some circumstances they are going to get a cheaper fare." OK, the fares structure *is* complicated, and I do think the matter will come to a head at some point, but in the intrerests of balance I should make the following points: 1. IT would be totally impossible for clerks to offer all the fares between two stations, plus all the *combinations* of fares between those stations. If you want ticket office queues to slow down by a factor of about 400% then push for all combinations of fares to be made available. Personally, I don't think it is unreasonable for these combination fares to be available only to those in the know. 2. As a general rule a genuinely "fair" fare policy should not rely on all the bargain fares being advanced purchase. For example compare and contrast Virgin fare policy with Chiltern policy. 3. When you have a situation where the fare from A to C is less than the fare from A to B that is usually because the A to C fare has received an increased discount. Evening out the fares will only result in the A to C fare being increased. 4. Similarly, where A to B plus B to C fares come out cheaper than an A to C fare it may be because the more local journeys have been kept low to increase this specific market. The longer distance journey, though more expensive reflects the actual fare and is probably well enough used to not requre any discounting. In short, the cheaper local fares might be keeping the smaller stations alive. I'm not saying the present fare amomalies are a good thing, but they are not necessarily a result of pure daftness as seems to be suggested by many posters. Roger http://rpm-railpics.fotopic.net/ http://therailwaystationgallery.fotopic.net/ http://therailticketgallery.fotopic.net/ |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
On Mon, 27 Dec 2004 20:13:18 -0000, "RPM"
wrote: 1. IT would be totally impossible for clerks to offer all the fares between two stations, plus all the *combinations* of fares between those stations. Yep it would be ridiculous, I have had clerks tell me when it's cheaper to buy a combination ticket, or a ticket beyond the destination I really want. 2. As a general rule a genuinely "fair" fare policy should not rely on all the bargain fares being advanced purchase. Could you explain? 3. When you have a situation where the fare from A to C is less than the fare from A to B that is usually because the A to C fare has received an increased discount. Evening out the fares will only result in the A to C fare being increased. but it will also reduce the A-B to fares, giving those people who don't know about the A-C ticket better off, the result farer as each ticket gets similar subsidies... Jim. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
"Jim Ley" wrote in message ... On Mon, 27 Dec 2004 20:13:18 -0000, "RPM" wrote: 1. IT would be totally impossible for clerks to offer all the fares between two stations, plus all the *combinations* of fares between those stations. Yep it would be ridiculous, I have had clerks tell me when it's cheaper to buy a combination ticket, or a ticket beyond the destination I really want. Clerks may be good enough to do it for you but they are not obliged to. This is for a very good reason. Is is simple enough to split a short journey, but for longer journeys the combinations increase almost exponentially. It becomes impractical to offer every possible combination. 2. As a general rule a genuinely "fair" fare policy should not rely on all the bargain fares being advanced purchase. Could you explain? Virgin make much of their cheap fares, but the quotas can be incredibly restrictive. Surely it is better to offer good value walk-on fares, concentrating on simple time restrictions to satisfy yield management issues. 3. When you have a situation where the fare from A to C is less than the fare from A to B that is usually because the A to C fare has received an increased discount. Evening out the fares will only result in the A to C fare being increased. but it will also reduce the A-B to fares, giving those people who don't know about the A-C ticket better off, the result farer as each ticket gets similar subsidies... It wouldn't though. It would just result in the A to C fare becoming equal to the existing A to B fare plus the B to C fare. Roger http://rpm-railpics.fotopic.net/ http://therailwaystationgallery.fotopic.net/ http://therailticketgallery.fotopic.net/ |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
"Jim Ley" wrote in message ... On Mon, 27 Dec 2004 20:13:18 -0000, "RPM" wrote: 1. IT would be totally impossible for clerks to offer all the fares between two stations, plus all the *combinations* of fares between those stations. Yep it would be ridiculous, I have had clerks tell me when it's cheaper to buy a combination ticket, or a ticket beyond the destination I really want. Clerks may be good enough to do it for you but they are not obliged to. This is for a very good reason. Is is simple enough to split a short journey, but for longer journeys the combinations increase almost exponentially. It becomes impractical to offer every possible combination. 2. As a general rule a genuinely "fair" fare policy should not rely on all the bargain fares being advanced purchase. Could you explain? Virgin make much of their cheap fares, but the quotas can be incredibly restrictive. Surely it is better to offer good value walk-on fares, concentrating on simple time restrictions to satisfy yield management issues. 3. When you have a situation where the fare from A to C is less than the fare from A to B that is usually because the A to C fare has received an increased discount. Evening out the fares will only result in the A to C fare being increased. but it will also reduce the A-B to fares, giving those people who don't know about the A-C ticket better off, the result farer as each ticket gets similar subsidies... It wouldn't though. It would just result in the A to C fare becoming equal to the existing A to B fare plus the B to C fare. Roger http://rpm-railpics.fotopic.net/ http://therailwaystationgallery.fotopic.net/ http://therailticketgallery.fotopic.net/ |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
"Biwah" wrote in message
... The Times December 27, 2004 Rail travellers' guide to becoming a legal fare dodger By Ben Webster [...] Alex Nelson, who runs a rail travel agency in Chester-le-Street, Co Durham, has a season ticket that covers the route between Ryde Esplanade and Ryde St Johns on the Isle of Wight. The two stations are at opposite ends of the town, and the season ticket is the cheapest in Britain at £104 a year. [...] http://www.timesonline.co.uk/newspap...416530,00.html Hmmm what an interesting character this Nelson - first he nicks all the railway-related domain names, then this... ;-) Good idea though, with the amount of routeing/ticketing q's posted here its obviously a popular subject. Cheers, -- James Hancock |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
"Biwah" wrote in message
... The Times December 27, 2004 Rail travellers' guide to becoming a legal fare dodger By Ben Webster [...] Alex Nelson, who runs a rail travel agency in Chester-le-Street, Co Durham, has a season ticket that covers the route between Ryde Esplanade and Ryde St Johns on the Isle of Wight. The two stations are at opposite ends of the town, and the season ticket is the cheapest in Britain at £104 a year. [...] http://www.timesonline.co.uk/newspap...416530,00.html Hmmm what an interesting character this Nelson - first he nicks all the railway-related domain names, then this... ;-) Good idea though, with the amount of routeing/ticketing q's posted here its obviously a popular subject. Cheers, -- James Hancock |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
On Mon, 27 Dec 2004 20:13:18 UTC, "RPM"
wrote: : 1. IT would be totally impossible for clerks to offer all the fares between : two stations, plus all the *combinations* of fares between those stations. If only someone would invent some sort of automatic calculating device for doing this sort of thing, eh? Perhaps when Mr Babbage has finshed his Analytical Engine ... Ian PS An algorithm very similar to that used in routefinding programmes would work fine. Replace times with costs and bob's your uncle. -- |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Airline Ticket Consolidators and Bucket Shops FAQ | Edward Hasbrouck | Air travel | 0 | February 16th, 2004 10:03 AM |
Airline Ticket Consolidators and Bucket Shops FAQ | Edward Hasbrouck | Air travel | 0 | January 16th, 2004 09:20 AM |
Airline Ticket Consolidators and Bucket Shops FAQ | Edward Hasbrouck | Air travel | 0 | December 15th, 2003 09:48 AM |
Airline Ticket Consolidators and Bucket Shops FAQ | Edward Hasbrouck | Air travel | 0 | November 9th, 2003 09:09 AM |
Airline Ticket Consolidators and Bucket Shops FAQ | Edward Hasbrouck | Air travel | 0 | October 10th, 2003 09:44 AM |